A Pouch or a Roll? Deciding Between the Venture Pouch and Tool Roll

We’ve all been there—standing in front of multiple options, trying to decide what makes the most sense for our lifestyle. Choosing between two items that serve a similar purpose can bring on decision paralysis. And ever since we introduced the Venture Pouch to our lineup, one question pops up again and again:

“Should I get the Tool Roll or the Venture Pouch?”

We get it. They both look great, they’re functional, and they seem to solve similar problems. But, as they say, the devil’s in the details. This blog post is here to guide you through the nuances, helping you decide which one deserves a spot in your everyday carry (EDC) lineup. Whether you’re an artist, an adventurer, or just someone who loves practical (and stylish) gear, we’ll break it all down.

Let’s get right into it!

First Things First: Practical Perspectives

Before jumping into details, let’s hear from Ben Vallack, an EDC enthusiast, on why he prefers the Tool Roll over a traditional bag:

"Most bags force you to choose between storage density and ease of access. A square case with foam inserts offers incredible organization but wastes space. On the flip side, tossing everything into a simple bag means tight storage but zero organization. The Tool Roll offers a rare middle ground—dense storage plus quick, full visibility of your gear when unrolled. This one’s by Lochby, made of waxed cotton, and it’s incredibly functional while looking great. Honestly, it’s the only product I was sent without obligation, and I love using it. Lochby is making some quality gear."

Photo Credit: @raven_the_pirate

Insight: The Tool Roll is perfect for users who value compact storage without sacrificing accessibility. But what about the Venture Pouch? Read on to see where it truly shines.

Breaking It Down: Key Factors to Consider

Knowing the nuances can make a world of difference when deciding between the Venture Pouch and the Tool Roll. Let’s take a closer look at four key factors to help you narrow it down.

1. Capacity: What Are You Carrying?

The capacity of your gear solution depends on what you’re carrying day-to-day. Here’s how the Tool Roll and Venture Pouch measure up:

• Tool Roll: Think slim and structured. It’s perfect for flat or compact tools like pens, knitting needles, cables, watercolors, and yes—even microphones. Its side pocket and three additional pockets work well for organizing minimalist essentials. For journal lovers: Lochby’s Pocket Journal Notebooks slide nicely into the back pockets. Ideal for those who prefer carrying high-density, flatter items.
• Venture Pouch: This pouch brings versatility to the table. While it can hold the same items as the Tool Roll (thanks to its elastic loops), it’s better equipped for bulkier or differently shaped items. Need to stash your glasses, handyman tools, or a small power bank? The Venture Pouch offers more spatial freedom with two separate sections—one with elastic loops for organization and another for free-form storage.

Photo credit: @artpherr

Verdict: Choose the Tool Roll for smaller, flatter items or artistic tools. Opt for the Venture Pouch when you need a bit more freedom in what you carry.

2. Closure Style: Hook or Zipper?

Everyone has closure preferences, and this simple detail might be the tipping point for you.

• Tool Roll: Secured by an adjustable hook-and-loop closure, the Tool Roll bundles everything snugly. The strap can be tightened or loosened depending on how much gear you’re carrying, making it flexible for both lighter loads and fully packed setups. Its design also includes flaps on the top and bottom that protect your items while adding extra security.
• Venture Pouch: Features a full zipper closure, ensuring all your gear is safely tucked in. While secure, the zipper design is fixed and doesn’t offer the same adjustability as the Tool Roll, meaning you’ll want to be mindful of how much you’re trying to pack in.

Photo credit: @rocketcityedc

Verdict: If you want a closure system that adapts to varying capacities, the Tool Roll's adjustable strap is a clear winner. If you prefer the dependability of a fully zipped pouch for total enclosure, the Venture Pouch is your best bet.

3. Bulk: How Much Space Do You Have?

For many of us, space matters. Whether you’re trying to fit everything into a daypack or keep your carry-on weight minimal, bulk is a significant factor.

• Tool Roll: Bundled into what can only be described as an adorable waxed canvas burrito, the Tool Roll is compact and adaptable. Its roll-up design means you can tighten things depending on the load, making it very bag-friendly.
• Venture Pouch: While slightly bulkier due to its zipper-closure and dual compartments, the Venture Pouch maintains a portable size. It’s structured but not rigid, meaning it can flex and adapt slightly to your packing needs.

Photo credit: @dannypacks_official

Verdict: If you’re working with limited bag space, the Tool Roll’s minimal profile might edge out the competition. If you want versatility and don’t mind a touch more bulk, the Venture Pouch is your pick.

4. Organization: Do You Like Compartments?

Organization is where these two shine but also diverge in how they approach it:

• Tool Roll: Simple, straightforward, and zoned for specific gear types. You have elastic loops for tools or pens and a few pockets for additional storage. Everything is visible at a glance when the roll is open. No digging, no distractions. Perfect for users who value simplicity in organization.
• Venture Pouch: A tad more intricate in its design. It offers two distinct sections: one with elastic loops for tools and the other a pouch-like compartment for bulkier items. This is perfect for those who prefer categorized organization—the kind where your multitool doesn’t end up rubbing against your water brush.

Photo credit: @beardedguy_outdoorexperience

Verdict: Go with the Tool Roll if you like the simplicity of a roll-and-secure system. The Venture Pouch is better for those who need compartmentalized organization.

Use Cases: Who’s Carrying What?

Still not sure? Let these real-world examples inspire your decision.

Venture Pouch Users

• Everyday Organization Seekers: Love a clutter-free bag? Use the Venture Pouch to keep chargers, cords, and pocket-sized items in one spot.
• Professionals & Tech Users: A powerhouse companion for techies. One user stashes their portable hard drives, chargers, and USB hubs all in the Venture Pouch.
• Travel Enthusiasts: Tired of rummaging through your duffel? Travel-ready individuals use the pouch to keep passports, toiletries, and travel essentials organized.
• Artists: Imagine sketching on-the-go with confidence. One artist uses their Venture Pouch to store paints, brushes, and mini palettes.

Explore detailed stories here.

Photo credit: @me_and_my_happydesk

Tool Roll Users

• Artists: Brushes, markers, watercolor pens, and even small notebooks stay secure in the Tool Roll. One user calls it their “mobile art studio.”
• EDC Enthusiasts: Prefer minimalist carry? Stash your flashlights, pocket knives, and multi-tools neatly in the roll.
• Fountain Pen Collectors: Protect your pens in style. Designed to prevent scratches, it’s a favorite among fountain pen users.

Discover more here.

Photo credit: @journal_wendy

The Final Call

Ultimately, both the Tool Roll and Venture Pouch are incredible additions to any EDC setup. If you’re after minimalist organization in a compact package, the Tool Roll might be your perfect sidekick. But if you’re looking for versatility and compartmentalized storage, the Venture Pouch may be your new best friend.

Whichever you choose, it’s not just gear storage—it’s a lifestyle upgrade. Happy carrying!